Pakistan Business Projection Industry Update Quarter 3 2012
$ 1 050
- May 2013
- by Business Monitor International
- 49
Core Views
With general elections scheduled for May 11, we believe the incumbent
Pakistan People's Party faces an uphill struggle for re-election. The
government's handling of the economy and its relationship with the
US are likely to be its key political liabilities. Unsurprisingly, based
on the consolidated results of two nationwide polls, the Pakistan
Muslim League-Nawaz is the current frontrunner.
Last year was one of Pakistan's deadliest and most violent on record,
which makes the Pakistani Taliban's recent peace overtures all the
more significant.
Economic data coming out of Pakistan paint a relatively encouraging
picture with the economy looking poised to record a faster rate of
growth this fiscal year, in line with our expectations.
While key structural headwinds have receded, they have not been
resolved. Therefore, we are happy to keep our FY2012/13 real GDP
forecast of 4.0%, just below the government's 4.3% target.
Setting aside our constructive macroeconomic outlook on the country,
we believe that a potential balance of payments crunch could quickly
undo the economic progress Pakistan has made in recent years.
Our view for gradual weakness in the rupee continues to play out
well. Given the balance of payments dynamics in play, we expect
this gradual depreciatory trend to persist largely unabated.
The government unveiled its Strategic Trade Policy Framework for
2012-2015, which specifically prioritised the need to boost the country's
export earnings. On balance, while the framework contains both
positive and negative elements, we believe that it should improve
the country's external trade prospects over the medium term.
Despite the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP)'s dovishness over the past
two years, we do not expect the reverse repo rate to be taken below
the 9.50% mark, taking into account rising inflationary pressure on
the back of the ongoing surge in broad money supply growth.
The government's budgetary performance in the first half of FY2012/13
was neither encouraging nor alarming as the half-year budget deficit
was largely unchanged from recent years. That said, the lack of
any major fiscal reform suggests to us that another potential fiscal
blowout could be store in Pakistan as deterioration in second-half
budget discipline – a recurring phenomenon – coupled with rising
electoral pressures could prove to be a dangerous mix.
The fiscal incentives introduced by the recently finalised and longawaited
Special Economic Zones Act, 2012 should help to alleviate
the weak state of investment activity in Pakistan. The recent law is
a welcome move from the government.
Major Forecast Changes
We have nudged up our end-FY2012/13 and end-FY2013/14 consumer
price inflation forecasts upwards to 8.5% and 9.0%, from
8.0% and 8.5% respectively.
Key Risks To Outlook
Upside Risks To Inflation: Should external financing fail to
materialise or should the government fail to mobilise its domestic
resource base, it could result in further budgetary borrowings from
the banking system, thus stoking inflation. Externally, still elevated
global food and energy prices remain of particular concern from
an inflationary standpoint.
Downside Risk To Policy Rate: While we do not expect any additional
rate cuts from the central bank, we highlight that should the
SBP's latest measure fail to result in a substantial improvement of
economic activity over the coming months, then the likelihood of
further easing down the line would certainly increase. In addition,
given the looming general elections, political considerations will likely
continue to weigh heavily on the central bank's actions.
Downside Risks To Growth: As previously mentioned, several
structural factors continue to pose significant headwinds to growth.
Should any of these intensify in the coming months, real GDP
growth for the year could very well fall below our 4.0% projection.
Furthermore, we caution that a low-to-medium probability external
payments crunch could derail the Pakistani economy.
Executive Summary 5
Core Views 5
Major Forecast Changes 5
Key Risks To Outlook 5
Chapter 1: Political Outlook 7
SWOT Analysis 7
BMI Political Risk Ratings 7
Domestic Politics 8
A Look Into A PML-N Led Government
Based on the consolidated results of two nationwide polls on voting intentions, the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) is the
current frontrunner in Pakistan's upcoming general elections, scheduled for May 11. In this article, we briefly outline what a PML-N-led
government would imply with regards to three of the country's most pressing issues: the rising fiscal deficit, the long-running energy
crisis, and the bleak security environment.
TABLE: POLITICAL OVERVIEW 8
Long-Term Political Outlook 10
Instability To Prevail, But Outright Collapse Unlikely
Pakistan is at risk of experiencing years of instability and militant activity, but an outright collapse of the state is unlikely unless the core
province of Punjab becomes ungovernable. Under such circumstances, we would not preclude a military coup. Meanwhile, owing to its
strategic importance, Pakistan's foreign allies will do everything they can to ensure stability.
TABLE: SCENARIO MATRIX - EVOLUTION OF STATE 11
TABLE: SCENARIO MATRIX - CENTRIFUGAL VERSUS CENTRIPETAL FORCES 12
Chapter 2: Economic Outlook 13
SWOT Analysis 13
BMI Economic Risk Ratings 13
Economic Activity 14
Risk Scenario: Severe External Payments Crunch Undoes Economy
According to most indications, the Pakistani economy is on track to record its highest annual real GDP growth rate since FY2006/07
(July-June) this fiscal year (FY2012/13), in line with our projection for full-year growth to come in at 4.0%. Setting aside our constructive
macroeconomic outlook on the country, we believe that a potential balance of payments crunch could quickly undo the economic
progress the country has made in recent years. In this article, we outline why and explore how such a scenario may manifest itself.
TABLE: ECONOMIC ACTIVITY 14
Monetary Policy 17
All Roads Point To Higher CPI
Price data coming out of Pakistan over the past few months have shown inflation softening yet again, running counter to our earlier
claim that headline consumer price inflation had bottomed out in November 2012. Nonetheless, we continue to believe that a reacceleration
of inflation is forthcoming given the ongoing surge of broad money supply growth. Furthermore, we note that other
measures of inflation continue to paint a less serene picture of current price conditions. We continue to believe that the central bank's
aggressive loosening cycle is over and that policy rates will remain on hold.
TABLE: MONETARY POLICY 17
Fiscal Policy 19
Calm Before Potential Fiscal Storm?
The government's budgetary performance in the first half of FY2012/13 (July-June) was neither encouraging nor alarming as the halfyear
budget deficit was largely unchanged from recent years. That said, the lack of any major fiscal reform (as indicated by the latest
numbers) suggests to us that a potential fiscal blowout could be in store in Pakistan as a deterioration in second half budget discipline
a recurring phenomenon - coupled with rising electoral pressures could prove to be a dangerous mix. Below, we highlight a few
obstacles to fiscal reform.
TABLE: FISCAL POLICY 19
Balance Of Payments 21
2012-2015 Trade Policy: The Good And The Bad
The government unveiled its Strategic Trade Policy Framework for 2012-2015, which specifically prioritises the need to boost the
country's export earnings. On balance, while the framework contains both positive (eg, the plans to rationalise tariff protection) and
negative (eg, the absence of any commitment to seek greater market access) elements, we believe that it should improve Pakistan's
external trade prospects in the years to come.
TABLE: CURRENT ACCOUNT 21
TABLE: RECENT TRADE AGREEMENTS 22
Chapter 3: 10-Year Forecast 25
The Pakistani Economy To 2022 25
Sustained Underperformance
Given Pakistan's ongoing security woes, and the lack of a clear resolution to them, we see a period of relatively subdued economic
growth for the years ahead. Indeed, while we acknowledge that Pakistan has the potential to enjoy economic growth as experienced
elsewhere in emerging Asia, we believe that conditions within the country will conspire against this - causing a protracted period of
underperformance.
TABLE: LONG-TERM MACROECONOMIC FORECASTS 25
Chapter 4: Business Environment 27
SWOT Analysis 27
BMI Business Environment Risk Ratings 27
Business Environment Outlook 28
TABLE: BMI BUSINESS AND OPERATION RISK RATINGS 28
TABLE: BMI LEGAL FRAMEWORK RATING 29
Infrastructure 30
TABLE: LABOUR FORCE QUALITY 31
TABLE: ASIA - ANNUAL FDI INFLOWS 32
TABLE: TRADE AND INVESTMENT RATINGS 33
TABLE: TOP EXPORT DESTINATIONS 34
Operational Risk 35
Chapter 5: Key Sectors 37
Defence & Security 37
TABLE: PAKISTAN'S DEFENCE EXPENDITURE, 2011-2017 38
Freight Transport 41
TABLE: AIR FREIGHT 43
TABLE: RAIL FREIGHT 43
TABLE: MARITIME FREIGHT 43
Other Key Sectors 45
TABLE: AUTOS SECTOR KEY INDICATORS 45
TABLE: FOOD AND DRINK SECTOR KEY INDICATORS 45
TABLE: INFRASTRUCTURE SECTOR KEY INDICATORS 45
TABLE: PHARMA SECTOR KEY INDICATORS 46
TABLE: TELECOMS SECTOR KEY INDICATORS 46
Chapter 6: BMI Global Assumptions 47
Global Outlook 47
Lowering Our US And Eurozone Growth Forecasts 47
TABLE: GLOBAL ASSUMPTIONS 47
TABLE: DEVELOPED STATES, REAL GDP GROWTH, % 48
TABLE: BMI VERSUS BLOOMBERG CONSENSUS REAL GDP GROWTH FORECASTS, % 48
TABLE: EMERGING MARKETS, REAL GDP GROWTH, % 49