Metamaterials: Technologies And Global Markets

Metamaterials: Technologies And Global Markets

STUDY GOALS AND OBJECTIVES

Metamaterials offer seemingly endless possibilities. However, intuition alone tells us that not all of these possibilities are likely to become reality. The goal of this report is to survey emerging metamaterials technologies and applications, identify those that are most likely to achieve significant commercial sales in the next 5 to 10 years, and develop quantitative estimates of potential sales.

The report’s approach is similar to that of BCC’s other recent report Global Medical Markets for Nanoscale Materials and Devices (HLC058A). Both reports generally avoid futuristic speculation about technology applications that might be possible 10 years or more into the future, focusing instead on applications that are expected make it to market by 2018.

The report’s specific objectives support this broad goal. These objectives include identifying the metamaterials with the greatest commercial potential in the 2008 to 2018 time frame, identifying market drivers and evaluating obstacles to their successful commercialization, and projecting their future sales.

INTENDED AUDIENCE

This report is intended especially for marketing executives, entrepreneurs, investors, venture capitalists, and other readers with a need to know where the emerging metamaterials market is headed over the next 5 to 10 years. Although the report is organized around specific technologies, it is largely non-technical in nature and coverage. That is, it is concerned less with theory and jargon than with what works, how much of the latter the market is likely to purchase, and at what price.

The report has not been written specifically for scientists and technologists. However, the report’s findings concerning the market for their work, including the availability of government and corporate research funding for different technologies and applications should interest them as well.

SCOPE AND FORMAT

The report addresses the emerging global market for metamaterials, including the classes of materials listed below. The common thread uniting this diverse group of materials is that all of them are artificial materials with characteristics usually not found in nature, and owe these characteristics to their structure rather than their constituent element or elements.

• Artificial dielectrics
  
  
• Negative refraction media
  
  
• Active terahertz materials (i.e., metamaterials respond magnetically to far infrared or terahertz (THz) electromagnetic radiation
  
  
• Chiral materials
  
  
• Photonic crystals
  
  
• Superconducting metamaterials

CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION

STUDY BACKGROUND

STUDY GOALS AND OBJECTIVES

INTENDED AUDIENCE

SCOPE AND FORMAT

INFORMATION SOURCES AND METHODOLOGY

ANALYST CREDENTIALS

RELATED BCC RESEARCH REPORTS

BCC ONLINE SERVICES

DISCLAIMER

CHAPTER TWO: EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

SUMMARY TABLE GLOBAL MARKET FOR METAMATERIALS

APPLICATIONS, BY TYPE OF MATERIAL, THROUGH ($ MILLIONS)

SUMMARY FIGURE GLOBAL MARKET FOR METAMATERIALS

APPLICATIONS, BY TYPE OF MATERIAL, 2007-2018 ($ MILLIONS)

CHAPTER THREE: OVERVIEW

GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF METAMATERIALS

DEFINITION

HISTORY

TYPES/APPLICATIONS OF METAMATERIALS

TABLE 1 MAJOR TYPES OF METAMATERIALS

TABLE 1 (CONTINUED)

ELECTROMAGNETIC METAMATERIALS

Artificial Dielectrics

Negative Refraction Media

Active Terahertz Metamaterials

Chiral Materials

Photonic Crystals

Superconducting Metamaterials

Magnetic Nanocomposites

ACOUSTIC METAMATERIALS

EXTREME-PARAMETER METAMATERIALS

OVERALL MARKET SIZE AND SEGMENTATION

MARKET SIZE

FIGURE 1 TRENDS IN GLOBAL MARKET FOR METAMATERIALS,

2007¨C2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TYPES OF METAMATERIALS

AVM067A ©¤ Metamaterials: Technologies and Global Markets

TABLE 2 GLOBAL MARKET FOR METAMATERIALS BY TYPE OF MATERIAL, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

FIGURE 2 TRENDS IN METAMATERIALS MARKET BY TYPE OF METAMATERIAL, 2007¨C2018 (% OF TOTAL MARKET) END USES

TABLE 3 GLOBAL MARKET FOR METAMATERIALS BY END-USE SECTOR, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

FIGURE 3 TRENDS IN METAMETERIALS MARKET BY END USE, 2007¨C2018 (% OF TOTAL MARKET)

CHAPTER FOUR: ARTIFICIAL DIELECTRICS: MATERIALS, END USES AND MARKETS, 2007 TO 2018

MATERIALS

PROPERTIES

APPLICATIONS

WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONS

AUTOMOTIVE RADAR

AIRBORNE ANTENNAS

MARKETS

SUMMARY

TABLE 4 PROJECTED MARKET FOR ARTIFICIAL DIELECTRICS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

FIGURE 4 TRENDS IN MARKET FOR ARTIFICIAL DIELECTRICS, 2007¨C2018 ($ MILLIONS)

FIGURE 5 TRENDS IN ARTIFICIAL DIELECTRICS MARKET BY TYPE OF APPLICATION, 2007¨C2018 (% OF TOTAL MARKET)

AUTOMOTIVE RADAR

TABLE 5 MARKET FOR AUTOMOTIVE RADAR APPLICATIONS,THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 6 MATERIALS CONSUMPTION ASSOCIATED WITHAUTOMOTIVE RADAR APPLICATIONS, THROUGH ($ MILLIONS)

AIRBORNE ANTENNAS

TABLE 7 AIRBORNE ANTENNAS AND RELATED MARKET FOR

METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS) WIRELESS COMMUNICATIONS

TABLE 8 GLOBAL MARKET FOR WIMAX DATA COMMUNICATION

EQUIPMENT AND POTENTIAL SUCCESSOR TECHNOLOGIES,THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 9 SMART ANTENNAS AND RELATED MARKET FOR

ARTIFICIAL DIELECTRICS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

AVM067A ©¤ Metamaterials: Technologies and Global Markets

CHAPTER FIVE: NEGATIVE REFRACTION MEDIA: MATERIALS, ENDUSES AND MARKETS, 2007 TO 2018

MATERIALS

PROPERTIES

FIGURE 6 NEGATIVE REFRACTION

EXAMPLES

Copper-Fiberglass Media

Gold Nanorods

Layered Ferromagnets and Superconductors

Nanoscale Silver

Silver Thin Films

Nanoscale Silver Mesh Structure

Silicon Nitride/Silver/Gold Prism Sandwich

Yttrium Vanadate Crystals

Teflon-Ceramic-Copper Capacitor Material

Naturally Occurring Negatively Refractive Materials

APPLICATIONS

OPTICAL MICROSCOPY

PHOTOLITHOGRAPHY

DATA STORAGE

OTHER POTENTIAL APPLICATIONS

MARKETS

SUMMARY

TABLE 10 PROJECTED MARKET FOR NEGATIVELY REFRACTIVE

METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 (MILLION $)

FIGURE 7 TRENDS IN NEGATIVELY REFRACTIVE

METAMATERIALS MARKET BY TYPE OF APPLICATION, 2007¨C2018 (% OF TOTAL MARKET)

OPTICAL MICROSCOPES

TABLE 11 METAMETERIALS MARKET IN OPTICAL MICROSCOPY

APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

NEAR-FIELD PHOTOLITHOGRAPHY

Near-field Photolithography (Continued)

TABLE 12 METAMETERIALS MARKET IN PHOTOLITHOGRAPHY APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

DATA STORAGE

TABLE 13 METAMETERIALS MARKET IN DATA STORAGE APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

MAGNETIC RESONANCE IMAGING

TABLE 14 METAMATERIALS MARKET IN MRI APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

Magnetic Resonance Imaging (Continued)

AVM067A ©¤ Metamaterials: Technologies and Global Markets

CHAPTER SIX: ACTIVE TERAHERTZ METAMATERIALS: MATERIALS, END USES AND MARKETS, 2007 TO 2018

MATERIALS

PROPERTIES

FIGURE 8 SPLIT RING RESONATOR

APPLICATIONS

NON DESTRUCTIVE TESTING

MEDICAL IMAGING

Intraoperative Imaging

Skin Cancer Detection

Clinical Dentistry

AIRPORT SECURITY

Airport Security (Continued)

MARKETS

SUMMARY

TABLE 15 PROJECTED MARKET FOR THZ ACTIVE

METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

FIGURE 9 TRENDS IN TERAHERZ ACTIVE METAMATERIALS

MARKET BY TYPE OF APPLICATION, 2007¨C2018 (% OF TOTAL MARKET)

AIRPORT SECURITY

TABLE 16 GLOBAL MARKET FOR TERAHERTZ AND OTHER

AIRPORT SECURITY SCREENING EQUIPMENT, THROUGH ($ MILLIONS)

NON-DESTRUCTIVE TESTING

TABLE 17 GLOBAL MARKET FOR TERAHERTZ AND OTHER

RADIOGRAPHIC NDT EQUIPMENT, THROUGH ($ MILLIONS)

MEDICAL IMAGING

TABLE 18 GLOBAL MARKET FOR TERAHERTZ MEDICAL IMAGING

APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 19 GLOBAL MARKET FOR TERAHERTZ ACTIVE

METAMATERIALS IN MEDICAL IMAGING APPLICATIONS,THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

Intraoperative Imaging

TABLE 20 GLOBAL MARKET FOR INTRAOPERATIVE IMAGING

EQUIMENT, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

FIGURE 10 INTRAOPERATIVE IMAGING TECHNOLOIGES MARKET

SHARES, 2007 (PERCENT OF TOTAL INTRAOPERATIVE IMAGING

EQUIPMENT SALES)

TABLE 21 GLOBAL MARKET FOR INTRAOPERATIVE TERAHERTZ

IMAGING EQUIMENT, 2007¨C2018 ($ MILLIONS)

AVM067A ©¤ Metamaterials: Technologies and Global Markets

Skin Cancer Detection

TABLE 22 GLOBAL MARKET FOR TERAHERTZ SKIN CANCER

IMAGING EQUIMENT, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

Clinical Dentistry

TABLE 23 GLOBAL MARKET FOR TERAHERTZ DENTAL CARIES

IMAGING EQUIMENT, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

CHAPTER SEVEN: CHIRAL MATERIALS: MATERIALS, END USES AND MARKETS, 2007 TO 2018 MATERIALS

FIGURE 11 CHIRALITY

PROPERTIES

Electromagnetic Chiral Metamaterials

Optical Activity

Circular Dichroism

Negative Refraction

Artificial Magnetism

Enantioselectivity

EXAMPLES

Optically Active Chiral Metamaterials

FIGURE 12 OPTICALLY ACTIVE CHIRAL METAMATERIAL

Asymmetric Catalysts

APPLICATIONS

POLARIZATION CODING OF QUANTUM INFORMATION

CIRCULAR DICHROISM SPECTROSCOPY

CHEMICAL AND PHARMACEUTICAL PRODUCTION

Chemical and Pharmaceutical ¡- (Continued)

MARKETS

SUMMARY

TABLE 24 PROJECTED MARKET FOR CHIRAL METAMATERIALS,THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

FIGURE 13 TRENDS IN MARKET FOR CHIRAL METAMATERIALS,2007¨C2018 ($ MILLIONS)

FIGURE 14 TRENDS IN CHIRAL MATERIALS MARKET BY TYPE OF

APPLICATION, 2007¨C2018 (% OF TOTAL MARKET)

QUANTUM INFORMATION PROCESSING

TABLE 25 METAMATERIALS MARKET IN QUANTUM ENCRYPTION

APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

CIRCULAR DICHROISM SPECTROSCOPY

TABLE 26 METAMATERIALS MARKET IN CIRCULAR DICHROISM

SPECTROSCOPY APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

CATALYSIS

AVM067A ©¤ Metamaterials: Technologies and Global Markets

TABLE 27 METAMATERIALS MARKET IN CIRCULAR DICHROISM

SPECTROSCOPY APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

Pharmaceuticals

TABLE 28 CONSUMPTON OF ASSYMETRIC CATALYSTS IN

PHARMACEUTICALS PRODUCTION, THROUGH ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 28 (CONTINUED)

FIGURE 15 TRENDS IN PHARMACEUTICAL MARKET FORASYMMETRIC CATALYSTS, 2007¨C2018 ($ MILLIONS)

Other Chemicals

TABLE 29 CONSUMPTON OF ASSYMETRIC CATALYSTS IN OTHERCHEMICALS PRODUCTION, THROUGH 2008 ($ MILLION)

CHAPTER EIGHT: PHOTONIC CRYSTALS: MATERIALS, END USESAND MARKETS, 2007 TO 2018

MATERIALS

PROPERTIES

FIGURE 16 PHOTONIC CRYSTAL STRUCTURE

Two Dimensional vs. Three Dimensional Crystals

FIGURE 17 2D VS. 3D PHOTONIC CRYSTALS

Defects

FIGURE 18 PHOTONIC CRYSTAL POINT DEFECT

Static vs. Tunable Crystals

COMPOSITION

FABRICATION

Micromachining

Microlithographic Techniques

Layer-by-Layer Fabrication

FIGURE 19 ¡°WOODPILE¡± STRUCTURE

Autocloning

FIGURE 20 AUTOCLONED CRYSTAL STRUCTURE

Holographic Lithography

Glancing Angle Deposition

Stack Methods

Low Temperature Deposition

Self-Assembly

Opal Method

Other Self-Assembly Techniques

Drawing and Extruding

APPLICATIONS

FIBER LASERS

FLAT PANEL DISPLAYS

AVM067A ©¤ Metamaterials: Technologies and Global Markets

HIGH-BRIGHTNESS LEDS

SENSORS

OPTICAL COMPUTING

DATA STORAGE

OPTICAL COMMUNICATIONS ADD/DROP FILTERS

SOLAR CELLS

OTHER APPLICATIONS

MARKETS

SUMMARY

TABLE 30 PROJECTED MARKET FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

FIGURE 21 GLOBAL MARKET TRENDS FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTAL

METAMATERIALS, 2007¨C2018 ($ MILLIONS)

FIGURE 22 TRENDS IN PHOTONIC CRYSTALS MARKET BY TYPE

OF APPLICATION, 2007¨C2018 (% OF TOTAL MARKET)

FIBER LASERS

TABLE 31 GLOBAL MARKET FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTAL FIBER USED IN FIBER LASER APPLICATIONS, THROUGH ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 32 GLOBAL MARKET FOR FIBER LASERS, THROUGH ($ MILLIONS)

HIGH BRIGHTNESS LEDS

TABLE 33 GLOBAL MARKET FOR HIGH-BRIGHTNESS LEDS,THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 34 GLOBAL CONSUMPTION OF PHOTONIC CRYSTALS IN

THE FABRICATION OF HB- LEDS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

SOLAR CELLS

TABLE 35 PROJECTED MARKET FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTAL-BASED

PHOTOVOLTAICS AND RELATED CONSUMPTION OF PHOTONIC

CRYSTALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

DATA STORAGE

TABLE 36 MARKET FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTAL-BASED DATE

STORAGE PRODUCTS AND RELATED CONSUMPTION OF

PHOTONIC CRYSTALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

SENSORS

TABLE 37 WORLD MARKETS FOR QUANTUM DOTS IN

BIODETECTION APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 38 WORLD MARKETS FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTAL

FLUORESCENCE ENHANCERS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

OPTICAL COMPUTING

TABLE 39 WORLD MARKETS FOR HIGH PERFORMANCE

PROCESSORS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

AVM067A ©¤ Metamaterials: Technologies and Global Markets

TABLE 40 WORLD MARKETS FOR HIGH PERFORMANCE ALLOPTICAL

PROCESSORS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

FLAT PANEL DISPLAYS

TABLE 41 WORLD MARKETS FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTAL-BASED

DISPLAYS AND RELATED CONSUMPTION OF PHOTONIC

CRYSTAL MATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

OPTICAL COMMUNICATIONS ADD/DROP FILTERS

TABLE 42 GLOBAL MARKET FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTAL ADD/DROP

FILTERS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

CHAPTER NINE: SUPERCONDUCTING METAMATERIALS:

MATERIALS, END USES AND MARKETS, 2007 TO 2018

MATERIALS

PROPERTIES

EXAMPLES

END USES

HIGH PERFORMANCE COMPUTERS

ELECTRICAL TRANSMISSION WIRES

MARKETS

SUMMARY

TABLE 43 PROJECTED MARKET FOR SUPERCONDUCTING

POLYMER METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

FIGURE 23 TRENDS IN SUPERCONDUCTING POLYMER

METAMATERIALS MARKET BY TYPE OF APPLICATION, 2007¨C2018 (% OF TOTAL MARKET)

FIGURE 23 (CONTINUED)

HIGH PERFORMANCE COMPUTERS

TABLE 44 WORLD MARKETS FOR SPECIALIZED HPC

PROCESSORS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 45 MARKET FOR SUPERCONDUCTING INTEGRATED

CIRCUITS USED IN QUANTUM AND OTHER HIGH

PERFORMANCE AND RELATED CONSUMPTION OF

METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

ELECTRICAL TRANSMISSION WIRES

TABLE 46 MARKET FOR SUPERCONDUCTING ELECTRIC

TRANSMISSION WIRES AND RELATED CONSUMPTION OF

METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

Electrical Transmission Wires (Continued)

CHAPTER TEN: EXTREME-PARAMETER METAMATERIALS:

MATERIALS, END USES AND MARKETS, 2007 TO 2018

MATERIALS

AVM067A ©¤ Metamaterials: Technologies and Global Markets

PROPERTIES

FABRICATION

Consolidation of Nanoparticles into Monolithics

Severe Plastic Deformation

EXAMPLES

Nanostructured Steel

High-Strength Titanium

END USES

MEDICAL DEVICES

Surgical Needles

High Strength Medical and Dental Implants

STEEL COATINGS AND STRUCTURAL STEEL

MARKETS

SUMMARY

TABLE 47 PROJECTED MARKET FOR EXTREME PARAMETER

METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

FIGURE 24 TRENDS IN EXTREME PARAMETER METAMATERIALS

MARKET BY TYPE OF APPLICATION, 2007¨C2018 (% OF TOTAL

MARKET)

MEDICAL DEVICES

TABLE 48 PROJECTED MEDICAL DEVICE MARKET FOR EXTREME

PARAMETER METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

Surgical Needles

TABLE 49 GLOBAL MARKET FOR NANOSTRUCTURED STEEL

SUTURE NEEDLES, 2007¨C2018 ($ MILLION)

High-Strength Medical and Dental Implants

TABLE 50 GLOBAL CONSUMPTION OF CONVENTIONAL AND

NANOSTURCTURED TITANIUM IN MEDICAL IMPLANTS,THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

STEEL COATINGS AND STRUCTURAL STEEL

TABLE 51 GLOBAL CONSUMPTION OF NANOSTRUCTURED STEEL,THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

Steel Coatings

TABLE 52 GLOBAL CONSUMPTION OF NANOSTRUCTURED STEEL

COATINGS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

Structural Steel

TABLE 53 GLOBAL CONSUMPTION OF NANOSTRUCTURED

STRUCTURAL STEEL, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

CHAPTER ELEVEN: MAGNETIC NANOCOMPOSITES: MATERIALS,END USES AND MARKETS, 2007 TO 2018

MATERIALS

AVM067A ©¤ Metamaterials: Technologies and Global Markets

PROPERTIES

FABRICATION

END USES

MAGNETIC REFRIGERATORS

SPINTRONICS

MARKETS

TABLE 54 GLOBAL CONSUMPTION OF MAGNETIC

NANOCOMPOSITES FOR ELECTRICAL AND ELECTRONIC

APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

CHAPTER TWELVE: ACOUSTIC METAMATERIALS: MATERIALS, END USES AND MARKETS, 2007 TO 2018

MATERIALS

PROPERTIES

FABRICATION

END USES

ULTRASOUND IMAGING

ACOUSTIC CLOAKS

SEISMIC PROTECTION

MARKETS

SUMMARY

TABLE 55 PROJECTED MARKET FOR ACOUSTIC METAMATERIALS,THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

FIGURE 25 TRENDS IN TERAHERZ ACTIVE METAMATERIALS

MARKET BY TYPE OF APPLICATION, 2007 TO 2018 (% OF TOTAL

MARKET)

ULTRASOUND IMAGING

TABLE 56 METAMATERIALS MARKET IN MEDICAL ULTRASOUND

APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

NOISE BARRIERS

TABLE 57 METAMATERIALS MARKET IN OUTDOOR NOISE

BARRIERS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

SEISMIC PROTECTION

TABLE 58 METAMATERIALS MARKET IN SEISMIC PROTECTION

APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

APPENDIX I: : COMPANY PROFILES

ALIGHT TECHNOLOGIES APS

ALPS ELECTRIC CO., LTD

COLOSSAL STORAGE CORP.

CRYSTAL FIBRE A/S

ERA TECHNOLOGY, LTD.

AVM067A ©¤ Metamaterials: Technologies and Global Markets

FIANIUM LTD

ICX TECHNOLOGIES

INFRAMAT CORP

JEM ENGINEERING LLC

KOHERAS A/S

LUMINUS DEVICES, INC.

LUXTERA, INC

NEOMAX CO., LTD

OMNIGUIDE, INC.

MESOPHOTONICS LIMITED

NANOSTEEL CO., INC

NEWPORT CORP

OMNIGUIDE, INC.

OPALUX INC

PHOTEON TECHNOLOGIES GMBH

PHOTONIC LATTICE, INC

RAYSPAN INC

ROOM TEMPERATURE SUPERCONDUCTORS, INC

SANDVIK MATERIALS TECHNOLOGY AB

TERAVIEW LTD

VACUUMSCHMELZE GMBH

APPENDIX II: PATENT ANALYSIS

FIGURE 26 RECENT U.S. METAMATERIALS-RELATED PATENTS

AND PATENT APPLICATIONS BY TYPE OF MATERIAL, AS OF 9/1/2008 (PERCENT OF US PATENTS AND PATENT

APPLICATIONS PENDING)

FIGURE 26 (CONTINUED)

FIGURE 27 RECENT U.S. METAMATERIALS-RELATED PATENTS AND PATENT APPLICATIONS (PERCENT OF U.S. PATENTS AND

PATENT APPLICATIONS PENDING)

FIGURE 28 NUMBER OF U.S. SUPERCONDUCTIVITY-RELATED

PATENTS AND APPLICATIONS, BY COUNTRY (NUMBER OF PATENTS)

TABLE 59 MAJOR U.S. METAMATERIALS PATENT PORTFOLIOS

(NUMBER OF PATENTS ISSUED THROUGH SEPTEMBER 1, 2008)

AVM067A ©¤ Metamaterials: Technologies and Global Markets

LIST OF TABLES

SUMMARY TABLE GLOBAL MARKET FOR METAMATERIALS APPLICATIONS, BY TYPE OF MATERIAL, THROUGH ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 1 MAJOR TYPES OF METAMATERIALS

TABLE 2 GLOBAL MARKET FOR METAMATERIALS BY TYPE OF MATERIAL, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 3 GLOBAL MARKET FOR METAMATERIALS BY END-USE SECTOR, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 4 PROJECTED MARKET FOR ARTIFICIAL DIELECTRICS,THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 5 MARKET FOR AUTOMOTIVE RADAR APPLICATIONS,THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 6 MATERIALS CONSUMPTION ASSOCIATED WITH

AUTOMOTIVE RADAR APPLICATIONS, THROUGH ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 7 AIRBORNE ANTENNAS AND RELATED MARKET FOR METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 8 GLOBAL MARKET FOR WIMAX DATA COMMUNICATION

EQUIPMENT AND POTENTIAL SUCCESSOR TECHNOLOGIES,THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 9 SMART ANTENNAS AND RELATED MARKET FOR

ARTIFICIAL DIELECTRICS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 10 PROJECTED MARKET FOR NEGATIVELY REFRACTIVE METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 (MILLION $)

TABLE 11 METAMETERIALS MARKET IN OPTICAL MICROSCOPY APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 12 METAMETERIALS MARKET IN PHOTOLITHOGRAPHY APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 13 METAMETERIALS MARKET IN DATA STORAGE APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 14 METAMATERIALS MARKET IN MRI APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 15 PROJECTED MARKET FOR THZ ACTIVE METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 16 GLOBAL MARKET FOR TERAHERTZ AND OTHER AIRPORT

SECURITY SCREENING EQUIPMENT, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 17 GLOBAL MARKET FOR TERAHERTZ AND OTHER

RADIOGRAPHIC NDT EQUIPMENT, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 18 GLOBAL MARKET FOR TERAHERTZ MEDICAL IMAGING

APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

AVM067A ©¤ Metamaterials: Technologies and Global Markets

TABLE 19 GLOBAL MARKET FOR TERAHERTZ ACTIVE

METAMATERIALS IN MEDICAL IMAGING APPLICATIONS,THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 20 GLOBAL MARKET FOR INTRAOPERATIVE IMAGING EQUIMENT, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 21 GLOBAL MARKET FOR INTRAOPERATIVE TERAHERTZ IMAGING EQUIMENT, 2007¨C2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 22 GLOBAL MARKET FOR TERAHERTZ SKIN CANCER IMAGING EQUIMENT, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 23 GLOBAL MARKET FOR TERAHERTZ DENTAL CARIES

IMAGING EQUIMENT, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 24 PROJECTED MARKET FOR CHIRAL METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 25 METAMATERIALS MARKET IN QUANTUM ENCRYPTION APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 26 METAMATERIALS MARKET IN CIRCULAR DICHROISM SPECTROSCOPY APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 27 METAMATERIALS MARKET IN CIRCULAR DICHROISM SPECTROSCOPY APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 28 CONSUMPTON OF ASSYMETRIC CATALYSTS IN

PHARMACEUTICALS PRODUCTION, THROUGH 2008 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 29 CONSUMPTON OF ASSYMETRIC CATALYSTS IN OTHER CHEMICALS PRODUCTION, THROUGH 2008 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 30 PROJECTED MARKET FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 31 GLOBAL MARKET FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTAL FIBER USED IN FIBER LASER APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 32 GLOBAL MARKET FOR FIBER LASERS, THROUGH ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 33 GLOBAL MARKET FOR HIGH-BRIGHTNESS LEDS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 34 GLOBAL CONSUMPTION OF PHOTONIC CRYSTALS IN THE

FABRICATION OF HB- LEDS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 35 PROJECTED MARKET FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTAL-BASED

PHOTOVOLTAICS AND RELATED CONSUMPTION OF PHOTONIC

CRYSTALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 36 MARKET FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTAL-BASED DATE STORAGE

PRODUCTS AND RELATED CONSUMPTION OF PHOTONIC

CRYSTALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 37 WORLD MARKETS FOR QUANTUM DOTS IN BIODETECTION APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

AVM067A ©¤ Metamaterials: Technologies and Global Markets

TABLE 38 WORLD MARKETS FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTAL FLUORESCENCE ENHANCERS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 39 WORLD MARKETS FOR HIGH PERFORMANCE PROCESSORS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 40 WORLD MARKETS FOR HIGH PERFORMANCE ALLOPTICAL PROCESSORS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 41 WORLD MARKETS FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTAL-BASED

DISPLAYS AND RELATED CONSUMPTION OF PHOTONIC CRYSTAL MATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 42 GLOBAL MARKET FOR PHOTONIC CRYSTAL ADD/DROP FILTERS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 43 PROJECTED MARKET FOR SUPERCONDUCTING POLYMER METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 44 WORLD MARKETS FOR SPECIALIZED HPC PROCESSORS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 45 MARKET FOR SUPERCONDUCTING INTEGRATED CIRCUITS USED IN QUANTUM AND OTHER HIGH PERFORMANCE

AND RELATED CONSUMPTION OF METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 46 MARKET FOR SUPERCONDUCTING ELECTRIC

TRANSMISSION WIRES AND RELATED CONSUMPTION OF METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 47 PROJECTED MARKET FOR EXTREME PARAMETER METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 48 PROJECTED MEDICAL DEVICE MARKET FOR EXTREME PARAMETER METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 49 GLOBAL MARKET FOR NANOSTRUCTURED STEEL SUTURE NEEDLES, 2007¨C2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 50 GLOBAL CONSUMPTION OF CONVENTIONAL AND

NANOSTURCTURED TITANIUM IN MEDICAL IMPLANTS,

THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 51 GLOBAL CONSUMPTION OF NANOSTRUCTURED STEEL, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 52 GLOBAL CONSUMPTION OF NANOSTRUCTURED STEEL COATINGS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 53 GLOBAL CONSUMPTION OF NANOSTRUCTURED STRUCTURAL STEEL, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 54 GLOBAL CONSUMPTION OF MAGNETIC

NANOCOMPOSITES FOR ELECTRICAL AND ELECTRONIC APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 55 PROJECTED MARKET FOR ACOUSTIC METAMATERIALS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

AVM067A ©¤ Metamaterials: Technologies and Global Markets

TABLE 56 METAMATERIALS MARKET IN MEDICAL ULTRASOUND APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 57 METAMATERIALS MARKET IN OUTDOOR NOISE BARRIERS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLIONS)

TABLE 58 METAMATERIALS MARKET IN SEISMIC PROTECTION APPLICATIONS, THROUGH 2018 ($ MILLION)

TABLE 59 MAJOR U.S. METAMATERIALS PATENT PORTFOLIOS (NUMBER OF PATENTS ISSUED THROUGH SEPTEMBER 1, 2008)